Jump to content

Consumptive uses and losses: Difference between revisions

From coloradoriverscience.org
 
(56 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
==Overview==
==Overview==


'''NOTE:''' ''In 2024-25, Reclamation made significant changes in how Lower Basin CUL are calculated and reported. In late February 2026, a figure and several paragraphs on this page that summarized basinwide CUL values were removed as they reflected previous, outdated data. New summary information will be added to this page later in 2026.''
Knowing how much water is being ''used''–and for what purposes–is central to water resource management. Accurately quantifying use can be challenging at the scale of the individual water user, especially in agriculture. In gathering water use data at the basin scale, these challenges are compounded by the varying uncertainties in quantification across uses, inconsistent reporting, and variable terminology.  


Knowing how much water is being ''used''–and for what purposes–is central to water resource management. Accurately quantifying use can be challenging at the scale of the individual water user, especially in agriculture. In gathering water use data at the basin scale, these challenges are compounded by the varying uncertainties in quantification across uses, inconsistent reporting, and variable terminology.  
The terminology typically used in reporting by Reclamation, the basin states, and other analysts is ''consumptive uses'' (CU) and ''losses''. The combination of these two terms, often abbreviated as CUL, is the counterpart to supply in the water-balance equation.


The terminology used in reporting by Reclamation and the basin states is ''consumptive uses'' (CU) and ''losses''. The combination of these two terms, sometimes abbreviated as CUL, is the counterpart to supply in the water-balance equation.
''Consumptive uses'' refers to water that is diverted from a stream or river for any beneficial use (agriculture, municipal use, power-plant cooling, etc.), ''minus'' any return flows that would then be available to a downstream user on that same stream or river. When water is diverted from the Colorado River and exported for use in another basin (e.g., the South Platte River in Colorado), then the entire diverted amount is treated as consumptive use with respect to the Colorado River, since any return flows take place in that other river system.  


''Consumptive uses'' refers to water that is diverted from a stream or river for any beneficial use (agriculture, municipal use, power-plant cooling, etc.), ''minus'' any return flows that would then be available to a downstream user on that same stream or river. When water is diverted from the Colorado River and used in another basin (e.g., Colorado’s Front Range), then the entire diverted amount is treated as consumptive use with respect to the Colorado River, since any return flows would take place in a different river system.  
''Losses'' refers to depletions of water apart from beneficial uses. In the Colorado River Basin, the largest category of "losses" is reservoir evaporation; in Reclamation's current reporting of CUL (see below), reservoir evaporation is the only type of "losses" that are included. Reclamation's previous reporting of CUL included the "transit losses" along the mainstem below Lake Mead to evaporation from the river channel and transpiration from phreatophytic vegetation adjacent to the river channel. Similarly, the 2024 analysis of basin CUL by Richter et al. (see below) includes evapotranspiration from ripiarian and wetland areas in both the Upper and Lower basins. Seepage into, and storage within, reservoir banks, river banks, and river beds, is not treated as a loss, since the water is likely to return to the channel later in time or further downstream.


''Losses'' refers to depletions of water apart from beneficial uses; in the Colorado River Basin losses come primarily from (1) reservoir evaporation and (2) ''transit'' losses. The latter is the loss of water to evaporation and phreatophytic vegetation within and adjacent to the river channel, the mainstem below Lake Mead.  Seepage into, and storage within, the river banks is not treated as a loss, since the water is likely to return to the channel later in time or further downstream.
==Reclamation reporting of consumptive uses and losses (CUL) data==
[[File: CUL CRB map.png|thumb|500px|'''Figure 1.''' Reporting areas used by Reclamation in Upper Basin and Lower Basin CUL accounting and reports. (Source: Reclamation)]]


==Data and tools==
[[File: CUL CRB breakdown.png|thumb|500px|'''Figure 2.''' Average annual Colorado River System consumptive uses and losses (CUL) for the period 2015-2024. (Source: Reclamation)]]
<onlyinclude>
===Reclamation reporting of consumptive uses and losses (CUL) data===
Consumptive uses and losses (CUL) reports are prepared by Reclamation pursuant to the Colorado River Basin Project Act of 1968 (Public Law 90 537), covering major uses within each basin (Upper and Lower) of the Colorado River.


Prior to 2006, 5-year CUL reports that covered both the Upper Basin and Lower Basin (including deliveries to Mexico) were made available. After 2006, the 5-year CUL reports only covered the Upper Basin.  
Consumptive uses and losses (CUL) reports and data are prepared by Reclamation pursuant to the Colorado River Basin Project Act of 1968 (Public Law 90-537). The reports and data present estimates of anthropogenic consumptive uses and losses for the Colorado River System for each calendar year from 1971 and the data are categorized by type of use, reporting area, and by individual state.


In 2024-25 Reclamation [https://www.usbr.gov/lc/region/g4000/4200Rpts/CULReport/1971-2024%20Lower%20Colorado%20River%20System%20CUL%20Methods%20Manual.pdf made significant changes in how Lower Basin CUL data are calculated and reported], and has recalculated historical CUL data for the Lower Basin. Over the same period, Reclamation [https://www.usbr.gov/uc/DocLibrary/Reports/ConsumptiveUsesLosses/uc-ucrs-cul-methodsmanual1991-2025-508-20250800.pdf implemented an improved method for estimating agricultural consumptive use] in the Upper Basin, and likewise recalculated historical CUL data for the Upper Basin using that method. In addition to traditional reporting, Reclamation has developed interactive visualization tools for the recalculated CUL data.
In 2024 and 2025 Reclamation [https://www.usbr.gov/lc/region/g4000/4200Rpts/CULReport/1971-2024%20Lower%20Colorado%20River%20System%20CUL%20Methods%20Manual.pdf made significant changes in how Lower Basin CUL data are calculated and reported], and has recalculated historical CUL data for the Lower Basin. Over the same period, Reclamation [https://www.usbr.gov/uc/DocLibrary/Reports/ConsumptiveUsesLosses/uc-ucrs-cul-methodsmanual1991-2025-508-20250800.pdf implemented an improved method for estimating agricultural consumptive use] in the Upper Basin, and likewise recalculated historical CUL data for the Upper Basin.


''Recalculated CUL data:''
Annual data for the Upper and Lower Colorado River Systems are calculated and reported by Reclamation’s respective regional offices, and joint reports covering five-year periods are published with system-wide summaries. Methodologies between the two basins are generally consistent, with any differences highlighted in either the [https://www.usbr.gov/uc/DocLibrary/Reports/ConsumptiveUsesLosses/uc-ucrs-cul-methodsmanual1991-2025-508-20250800.pdf Upper Colorado Basin Region’s Methodology Manual], or the [https://www.usbr.gov/lc/region/g4000/4200Rpts/CULReport/1971-2024%20Lower%20Colorado%20River%20System%20CUL%20Methods%20Manual.pdf Lower Colorado Basin Region’s Methodology Manual].


*[https://app.powerbigov.us/view?r=eyJrIjoiMGNjNjNkOTEtMjAwOS00MjI2LTk2NGYtNDdmMWU1MDc3NDNhIiwidCI6IjA2OTNiNWJhLTRiMTgtNGQ3Yi05MzQxLWYzMmY0MDBhNTQ5NCJ9&embedImagePlaceholder=true&pageName=2b0439aad757fee9d1ac '''Upper Basin CUL Data Visualization Tool, 1971-2024''']
Important considerations for interpreting Reclamation’s CUL Data:


*[https://app.powerbigov.us/view?r=eyJrIjoiMTg3Y2UzMjMtMzQyNC00ODYyLThkODQtODlhZWE2OTM5ODQzIiwidCI6IjA2OTNiNWJhLTRiMTgtNGQ3Yi05MzQxLWYzMmY0MDBhNTQ5NCJ9&embedImagePlaceholder=true '''Lower Basin CUL Data Visualization Tool, 1971-2024''']
# Only anthropogenic uses and losses are reported. Natural evapotranspiration, (e.g., from riparian areas) and losses (e.g., natural lakes/river evaporation) are not reported in Reclamation's CUL data.
# Lower Basin CUL data include mainstream and tributary uses (see Figure 1).  Mainstream data are derived from [https://www.usbr.gov/lc/region/g4000/wtracct.html#:~:text=Water%20Accounting%20Reports,-The Reclamation’s annual Colorado River Water Accounting Report] and do not use the same methods as the tributary areas.
# Use categories (agriculture, municipal and industrial, thermal electric power, etc.) are assigned only to water used within the boundary of the hydrologic Colorado River Basin. Water that is exported out of the basin, e.g., to Colorado's Front Range, southern California urban areas, and the Imperial and Coachella valleys, is reported as an export and not assigned to a more specific use category (Figure 2).


*[https://www.usbr.gov/lc/region/g4000/4200Rpts/CULReport/1971-2005%20Lower%20Colorado%20River%20System%20Recalculated%20CUL%20Report.pdf '''Lower Basin CUL Report - Recalculated 1971-2005''']
==Data and tools==
<onlyinclude>
===Reclamation CUL reports and data===


''Legacy CUL data:''
Reclamation's CUL data for the Upper and Lower basins are now available (1) as Excel files containing monthly data aggregated at the HUC8 watershed level within a given state, (2) via visualization tools that display annual data aggregated at the state level, and (3) in the traditional 5-year reports. Note that only some 5-year reports have been re-issued using the updated CUL data.


* [https://www.usbr.gov/uc/DocLibrary/Reports/ConsumptiveUsesLosses/20220214-ProvisionalUpperColoradoRiverBasin2016-2020-CULReport-508-UCRO.pdf '''Upper Basin CUL reports (2016–2020)]
* [https://www.usbr.gov/uc/DocLibrary/reports.html#coloradoriversystem:~:text=Colorado%20River%20System%20%E2%80%93%20Consumptive%20Uses%20and%20Losses%20Reports '''Upper Basin CUL Reports & Data''']
** [https://app.powerbigov.us/view?r=eyJrIjoiMGNjNjNkOTEtMjAwOS00MjI2LTk2NGYtNDdmMWU1MDc3NDNhIiwidCI6IjA2OTNiNWJhLTRiMTgtNGQ3Yi05MzQxLWYzMmY0MDBhNTQ5NCJ9&embedImagePlaceholder=true&pageName=2b0439aad757fee9d1ac '''Upper Basin CUL Data Visualization Tool, 1971-2024''']
* [https://www.usbr.gov/lc/region/g4000/wtracct.html#:~:text=Colorado%20River%20System%20Consumptive%20Uses%20and%20Losses%20Reports'''Lower Basin CUL Reports & Data''']
** [https://app.powerbigov.us/view?r=eyJrIjoiMTg3Y2UzMjMtMzQyNC00ODYyLThkODQtODlhZWE2OTM5ODQzIiwidCI6IjA2OTNiNWJhLTRiMTgtNGQ3Yi05MzQxLWYzMmY0MDBhNTQ5NCJ9&embedImagePlaceholder=true '''Lower Basin CUL Data Visualization Tool, 1971-2024''']  


* [https://www.usbr.gov/uc/DocLibrary/Reports/ConsumptiveUsesLosses/20191000-ProvisionalUpperColoradoRiverBasin2011-2015-CULReport-508-UCRO.pdf '''Upper Basin CUL report (2011–2015)''']
Also, since 1964, Lower Basin diversions and consumptive uses, and deliveries to Mexico, have been summarized in the annual Water Accounting Reports, but these reports do not contain estimates of Lower Basin reservoir evaporation or other losses.  


* [https://www.usbr.gov/uc/DocLibrary/Reports/ConsumptiveUsesLosses/20170800-FinalUpperColoradoRiverBasin2006-2010-CULReport-508-UCRO.pdf '''Upper Basin CUL report (2006–2010)''']
* [https://www.usbr.gov/lc/region/g4000/wtracct.html#:~:text=Water%20Accounting%20Reports,-The '''Lower Basin Annual Water Accounting Reports (1964–2024)''']


* [https://www.usbr.gov/uc/envdocs/plans.html#CCULR '''Upper Basin & Lower Basin 5-year CUL reports (1971–2005)''']
===Richter et al. (2024) study and data===


Also, since 1964, Lower Basin diversions and consumptive uses and deliveries to Mexico have been summarized in the annual Water Accounting Reports, but these reports do not contain estimates of Lower Basin reservoir evaporation or other losses.  
In 2024, Brian Richter and others analyzed primary data sources (such as Reclamation CUL reports) and crop and riparian/wetland evapotranspiration (ET) estimates, to compile a basinwide water budget based on average consumptive water use (i.e., CUL) over the period 2000–2019. There are some key differences between the Richter et al. data and Reclamation's official CUL data: Richter et al. include riparian and wetland ET as a system loss; they provide sectoral breakdowns for water used in the Gila River watershed, water exported outside of the Colorado River Basin, and water used by Mexico; and they provide crop-specific breakdowns of agricultural water use throughout the Basin.  
 
* [https://www.nature.com/articles/s43247-024-01291-0 '''Richter et al. (2024) study: New water accounting reveals why the Colorado River no longer reaches the sea''']
 
* [https://www.hydroshare.org/resource/2098ae29ae704d9aacfd08e030690392/ '''Richter et al. (2024) data''' ]


* [https://www.usbr.gov/lc/region/g4000/wtracct.html '''Lower Basin Annual Water Accounting Reports (1964–2024)''']
</onlyinclude>
</onlyinclude>


==Additional resources==
==Additional resources==
===[https://www.usbr.gov/lc/region/programs/crbstudy/finalreport/Technical%20Report%20C%20-%20Water%20Demand%20Assessment/TR-C-Water_Demand_Assessmemt_FINAL.pdf Colorado River Basin Water Supply and Demand Study - Technical Report C]===  
===[https://www.usbr.gov/lc/region/programs/crbstudy/finalreport/Technical%20Report%20C%20-%20Water%20Demand%20Assessment/TR-C-Water_Demand_Assessmemt_FINAL.pdf Colorado River Basin Water Supply and Demand Study - Technical Report C]===  
Technical Report C (Water Demand Assessment) of the 2012 Basin Study, in Section 2.4 summarizes historical trends (1971-2010) in basin water use, including municipal use.  
Technical Report C (Water Demand Assessment) of the 2012 Basin Study, in Section 2.4 summarizes historical trends (1971-2010) in basin water use, including municipal use.  
Line 49: Line 58:
===[https://qcnr.usu.edu/coloradoriver/files/news/White-Paper-2.pdf Water Resource Modeling of the Colorado River: Present and Future Strategies]===
===[https://qcnr.usu.edu/coloradoriver/files/news/White-Paper-2.pdf Water Resource Modeling of the Colorado River: Present and Future Strategies]===
The Center for Colorado River Studies at Utah State U. published this 2019 overview of water resource modeling in the Colorado River. Page 33 lists the 2000-2017 averages for different components of basinwide CUL.
The Center for Colorado River Studies at Utah State U. published this 2019 overview of water resource modeling in the Colorado River. Page 33 lists the 2000-2017 averages for different components of basinwide CUL.
===[https://pubs.usgs.gov/sir/2018/5021/sir20185021.pdf Comparison of U.S. Geological Survey and Bureau of Reclamation Water-Use Reporting in the Colorado River Basin]===
This 2019 report compares the two agencies’ water-use information programs in the Colorado River Basin, describing the legal drivers for each program, clarifying confusing terminology, comparing the methods used, and contrasting the information reported by each agency.


<!-- BEGIN Comment
<!-- BEGIN Comment

Latest revision as of 10:55, 27 May 2026

Overview

Knowing how much water is being used–and for what purposes–is central to water resource management. Accurately quantifying use can be challenging at the scale of the individual water user, especially in agriculture. In gathering water use data at the basin scale, these challenges are compounded by the varying uncertainties in quantification across uses, inconsistent reporting, and variable terminology.

The terminology typically used in reporting by Reclamation, the basin states, and other analysts is consumptive uses (CU) and losses. The combination of these two terms, often abbreviated as CUL, is the counterpart to supply in the water-balance equation.

Consumptive uses refers to water that is diverted from a stream or river for any beneficial use (agriculture, municipal use, power-plant cooling, etc.), minus any return flows that would then be available to a downstream user on that same stream or river. When water is diverted from the Colorado River and exported for use in another basin (e.g., the South Platte River in Colorado), then the entire diverted amount is treated as consumptive use with respect to the Colorado River, since any return flows take place in that other river system.

Losses refers to depletions of water apart from beneficial uses. In the Colorado River Basin, the largest category of "losses" is reservoir evaporation; in Reclamation's current reporting of CUL (see below), reservoir evaporation is the only type of "losses" that are included. Reclamation's previous reporting of CUL included the "transit losses" along the mainstem below Lake Mead to evaporation from the river channel and transpiration from phreatophytic vegetation adjacent to the river channel. Similarly, the 2024 analysis of basin CUL by Richter et al. (see below) includes evapotranspiration from ripiarian and wetland areas in both the Upper and Lower basins. Seepage into, and storage within, reservoir banks, river banks, and river beds, is not treated as a loss, since the water is likely to return to the channel later in time or further downstream.

Reclamation reporting of consumptive uses and losses (CUL) data

Figure 1. Reporting areas used by Reclamation in Upper Basin and Lower Basin CUL accounting and reports. (Source: Reclamation)
Figure 2. Average annual Colorado River System consumptive uses and losses (CUL) for the period 2015-2024. (Source: Reclamation)

Consumptive uses and losses (CUL) reports and data are prepared by Reclamation pursuant to the Colorado River Basin Project Act of 1968 (Public Law 90-537). The reports and data present estimates of anthropogenic consumptive uses and losses for the Colorado River System for each calendar year from 1971 and the data are categorized by type of use, reporting area, and by individual state.

In 2024 and 2025 Reclamation made significant changes in how Lower Basin CUL data are calculated and reported, and has recalculated historical CUL data for the Lower Basin. Over the same period, Reclamation implemented an improved method for estimating agricultural consumptive use in the Upper Basin, and likewise recalculated historical CUL data for the Upper Basin.

Annual data for the Upper and Lower Colorado River Systems are calculated and reported by Reclamation’s respective regional offices, and joint reports covering five-year periods are published with system-wide summaries. Methodologies between the two basins are generally consistent, with any differences highlighted in either the Upper Colorado Basin Region’s Methodology Manual, or the Lower Colorado Basin Region’s Methodology Manual.

Important considerations for interpreting Reclamation’s CUL Data:

  1. Only anthropogenic uses and losses are reported. Natural evapotranspiration, (e.g., from riparian areas) and losses (e.g., natural lakes/river evaporation) are not reported in Reclamation's CUL data.
  2. Lower Basin CUL data include mainstream and tributary uses (see Figure 1). Mainstream data are derived from Reclamation’s annual Colorado River Water Accounting Report and do not use the same methods as the tributary areas.
  3. Use categories (agriculture, municipal and industrial, thermal electric power, etc.) are assigned only to water used within the boundary of the hydrologic Colorado River Basin. Water that is exported out of the basin, e.g., to Colorado's Front Range, southern California urban areas, and the Imperial and Coachella valleys, is reported as an export and not assigned to a more specific use category (Figure 2).

Data and tools

Reclamation CUL reports and data

Reclamation's CUL data for the Upper and Lower basins are now available (1) as Excel files containing monthly data aggregated at the HUC8 watershed level within a given state, (2) via visualization tools that display annual data aggregated at the state level, and (3) in the traditional 5-year reports. Note that only some 5-year reports have been re-issued using the updated CUL data.

Also, since 1964, Lower Basin diversions and consumptive uses, and deliveries to Mexico, have been summarized in the annual Water Accounting Reports, but these reports do not contain estimates of Lower Basin reservoir evaporation or other losses.

Richter et al. (2024) study and data

In 2024, Brian Richter and others analyzed primary data sources (such as Reclamation CUL reports) and crop and riparian/wetland evapotranspiration (ET) estimates, to compile a basinwide water budget based on average consumptive water use (i.e., CUL) over the period 2000–2019. There are some key differences between the Richter et al. data and Reclamation's official CUL data: Richter et al. include riparian and wetland ET as a system loss; they provide sectoral breakdowns for water used in the Gila River watershed, water exported outside of the Colorado River Basin, and water used by Mexico; and they provide crop-specific breakdowns of agricultural water use throughout the Basin.


Additional resources

Colorado River Basin Water Supply and Demand Study - Technical Report C

Technical Report C (Water Demand Assessment) of the 2012 Basin Study, in Section 2.4 summarizes historical trends (1971-2010) in basin water use, including municipal use.

Water Resource Modeling of the Colorado River: Present and Future Strategies

The Center for Colorado River Studies at Utah State U. published this 2019 overview of water resource modeling in the Colorado River. Page 33 lists the 2000-2017 averages for different components of basinwide CUL.

Comparison of U.S. Geological Survey and Bureau of Reclamation Water-Use Reporting in the Colorado River Basin

This 2019 report compares the two agencies’ water-use information programs in the Colorado River Basin, describing the legal drivers for each program, clarifying confusing terminology, comparing the methods used, and contrasting the information reported by each agency.